So Chris’ birthday fell on a Monday this year – 2 days ago to be exact! Truth be told, I wasn’t going to cook for him this year – he really wanted to visit a new craft Wagyu Beef burger bar that just recently opened up & they also happened to have a really good selection of bourbon, but alas, they are not open on Monday. So we improvised! ((& I personally think this improv was so good that I OBVIOUSLY had to write a mid-week entry about it!))
He asked for Filets, which he offered to grill, and said I could surprise him with sides. Easy! & just because I’m the way that I am, I went ahead & bought Applewood Smoked Bacon to make wrapped Filets just to impress him further! Hell yes! Just like I like it – I’m sure no one else would complain either.
ANYWAY. So I was running through all the viable options in my head for a killer birthday dinner, but within reason. It was a Monday night & I wanted to try something *new* but also relatively easy or something that wouldn’t require me to stand over it, because I knew the steaks wouldn’t take long to cook.
Scalloped Potatoes. Oh-Em-Geeeee they are so fucking good. Cheesy, rich, herbaceous, and surprisingly not too heavy. I make a Truffle Oil Scalloped Potato similar to this dish for Christmas & it is ALWAYS a hit.
However, Chris isn’t a huge fan of truffles – or any mushroom in general – booooo. He doesn’t know what he’s missing, but its his birthday so I’ll refrain from talking shit about his complete lack of knowledge & missing out on some other good food.
I tried to think how I could jazz up regular, ol’ Scalloped Potatoes & make them worthy of a birthday celebration. Well first, let’s realize the obvious & commit to more cheese. 3 cheeses to be exact – duh. The more the merrier! Multiples of cheese make everything more decadent – sold. What else? I could make it into a super-pretty arrangement with the potatoes – yes! OH! And I’ll add in grated garlic & a super-fresh herb mixture just to make everything seem all the more elevated – got it!
I also tried out a recipe from @the_chunky_chef (her handle is *almost* as good as mine! I had a good laugh) – I made her Sautéed Peas with Shallots & Prosciutto – it was SO GOOD. It also boasted a 15 minute start-to-finish time too so I figured this side dish would be perfect to try out while my potatoes were finishing up. She has some great recipes going on – you can find her complete list of recipes on Pinterest & a link in her Instagram bio!
***my only addition was a few squeezes of fresh lemon juice – it needed a little acid to take away the frozen taste of the peas & to brighten up the saltiness of the prosciutto***
Side Note – I really like making a design when I make Scalloped Potatoes because, obviously, THE MOST fancy – but also, it reminds me of Remy when he makes his Ratatouille dish in the beautiful circular shape. Plus who wouldn’t want to feel like the Chef in Ratatouille, except there’s no cute little rat in my hat yanking my hair to help this bitch out.
I’m aware that *most* Scalloped Potato recipes use white cheeses – well, this isn’t *most* Scalloped Potato recipes & if you haven’t heard by now, I don’t really give a shit how things *should* be done because where’s the fun in that??
Importantly, the 2 gadgets that are an absolute MUST for this dish to be a success : cast iron skillet & a Mandolin Slicer. The Cast Iron Skillet has a heavy bottom which heats up like none other – to give your potatoes a beautiful crust down on the bottom layer. Don’t try it in another pan – just do it. The Mandolin Slicer can definitely be scary as shit to use – so the words of advice I’ll give you is : you better use that damn guard & do not drink alcohol before or during the use of the Mandolin Slicer. This is of the utmost importance because, duh, you wanna keep all your fingers, but also – the potato slices come out PERFECTLY shaped, the same size & it’s so much faster than using a knife – so just get one.
Potato choice is also insanely important. Yukon Gold & Russet potatoes are both the standard for mashed potatoes – but obviously I’m not writing about that, am I? White Potatoes are what I’ve always used for anything scalloped or au gratin – they are a creamy potato with a very thin skin that doesn’t need to be peeled – save time & cut down on another task, amirite? Butter Potatoes would also be a great choice, but definitely stay away from Red Potatoes. Their texture can get waxy and stiff – best to use red potatoes for roasting in the oven at a higher temp with olive oil & spices – SIGN ME UP — YUM.
I could seriously go on and onnnn about how much I love potatoes or what great uses they have, but again, that’s not what we came here for. So let’s get to it!
First & foremost, you DO want to select cheeses that melt easily & will play on the palate well together – Sharp Cheddar. The most versatile cheese. Not necessarily overlooked, but definitely under-appreciated. Not aged, but Wisconsin-branded – sharp cheddar has the ability to play up almost any other compilation of cheese without taking the attention away from itself – a true classic. An absolute necessity for the trio of cheeses in this dish.
Next up was a 4 month aged Gruyere. This cheese has an almost-sweet, nutty flavor that brings a beautiful depth to the potatoes themselves, plus it get ooey-gooey – perfect for Scalloped Potatoes! The age on this cheese was particularly important – it wasn’t sharp or pungent, it was slightly salty too, which paired perfectly with the other 2 cheeses. So please make note of what age of Gruyere you purchase when making this dish!
Lastly, I chose the classic red-wax Gouda. This cheese was a bit softer, definitely more mellow, but an insanely good melting choice. Gouda pairs well with heavier items – i.e. potatoes & filets! Plus Gouda is just one of my favorite cheeses to eat, hands down – it goes well with almost everything!
GADGETS / UTENSILS
· Mandolin Slicer
· 10” Cast Iron Skillet
· Garlic press (for very fine garlic)
INGREDIENTS
· 4-6 medium sized white potatoes, scrubbed & dried
· 12 cloves of garlic, crushed
· 1 TBS Fresh Rosemary, chopped fine
· 1 TBS Fresh Oregano, chopped fine
· 1 TBS Fresh Thyme, chopped fine
· 1 TSP salt
· 1 TSP black pepper
· 3 TBS butter, cubed (to dot the bottom of your pan)
· 6 oz shredded Sharp Cheddar cheese
· 6 oz shredded Gruyere cheese
· 6 oz shredded Gouda cheese
· 1 ½ cup Heavy Cream
INSTRUCTIONS
· Preheat your oven to 400 degrees.
· Cutting your 3 TBS of butter into smaller slivers, quarter the butter to dot the bottom of your cast iron skillet – this will ensure a beautiful crust on the bottom of your first layer of potatoes.
· Next, shit, please be careful, SLOWLY slice your potatoes to your desired thickness using the Mandolin Slicer. I personally like my scalloped potatoes to melt in my mouth, so I use the 1st setting (thin) and swipe away.
· Chop your herbs very finely and mix them in a small bowl with the S+P – mix them all together and set aside with a spoon. This will be sprinkled on over top your potato slices for each layer.
· Shred all 3 of your cheeses by hand – it adds to the fucking magic, ok? Labor of love. Don’t question it. Bagged shredded cheese has no business being here amongst the potatoes of nobility. Plus, I doubt you can even find already-shredded Gruyere. You, peasant. *eyerollllllll*
· Press all 12 cloves of garlic into a small bowl & set aside with a spoon. This will also be a layer to go alongside the herb mixture you made earlier.
· NOW YOU ARE READY TO START ASSEMBLING.
· Your cast iron pan *should* already be dotted with butter & your oven *should* be on its way to reaching 400 degrees…..if not, get with the damn program.
· The fun part is next! Layering your sliced potatoes and arranging them beautifully, overlapping very slightly, side-by-side, one-over-the-other, for the first layer on the bottom of your pan. The first layer should have the potatoes slightly coming halfway up the side of your cast iron – this allows the first layer to hold everyone that comes after & on top, together – for dear life.
· ((all in all, I probably used 90-100 potato slices for this dish – it doesn’t matter either way, just to give you a rough idea of how much to cut so you won’t be wasteful, and so you know how many layers total – I made 3))
· Once the first layer of your potatoes is complete, take 1/3 of your crushed garlic – shit, just eyeball it, ok? – and using the back of the spoon, try to gently spread your crushed garlic over your potato slices. It doesn’t have to be perfect – the crushed garlic is fine & won’t burn in the oven, but try not to allow it to completely clump.
· Next, take a spoonful of your S+P & herb mixture – sprinkle this evenly all over your layered potatoes too. This is actually important to sprinkle slowly & evenly so everything is seasoned properly.
· OMGGG, NOW FOR THE CHEESE – take a handful of each of your cheeses & sprinkle that down on top of everything as well. This should be beautiful & exciting – you just made your first full complete layer of 3 Cheese Scalloped Potatoes!
· Repeat this process 2 more times – if you are feeling your skillet is getting a little full during the process, first, just calm the fuck down. You can gently press down with your palms flat or with the back of a large spoon.
· FINALLY – once you have done your last potato layer, your last salt-bae, & your last cheese fairy….its time for something scary. Not really, but it seems something that shouldn’t be done as a last step. I feel you. Just trust me, okuuuur?
· Slowly, pour the Heavy Cream all over your Scalloped Potatoes – this final step will NOT have everyone *swimming* in liquid, but try to pay attention to any cracks or crevices where it seems open or there is an absence of cheese or potato – it happens & its ok. The heavy cream will bubble in the oven & the natural starch from the potatoes will thicken ON ITS OWN – hence why there’s nothing to fret about.
· Lastly, your cheese should be *wet* from the Heavy Cream, but again, not submerged. To prevent burning, take the back of a spoon and gently smooth down the cheese so it becomes one with the cream.
· Cover your Scalloped Potatoes with tin foil & carefully place them in the oven for 30 minutes.
· After your first 30 minute timer, turn your heat down to 375 – they should smell dreamy & be quite bubbly by now – and uncover your Scalloped Potatoes and set a timer for another 30 minutes.
· Your cheese will brown, not burn, and be quite bubbly.
· Your cast iron will be hot as shit so be careful.
· Your heavy cream should have set, and the entire pan should be heavy with the goodness of potatoes & 3 cheeses.
· Allow this to sit on your stovetop, covered with tin foil, or 10-15 minutes just to allow everything to continue firming up – this was when I made the Sautéed Peas dish!
My 3 Cheese Scalloped Potatoes will impress you, your mother-in-law, your frenemies – it impressed my husband *wink* which was all I was going for this time around!
If you have the extra time, this dish would be great crowd-pleaser for a potluck – you can always use a bigger cast iron skillet & double the recipe! These Scalloped Potatoes reheat well – they are even tasty cold, straight out of the fridge.
I hope you make this dish for someone you love, because obviously it takes a lot of prepping & we don’t do all that for people we feel lukewarm about. I’m sensing a pattern here – I’m only telling y’all to cook for people you love, because its true. Food is a way to show someone that you care, that you thought of them, and that you wanted to make something special with only them in mind – hence why it was the perfect birthday side dish! I hope you make this, enjoy it & make it over again – if you don’t, then same.
See below for the birthday filets & crème brulee for dessert!
oh hell yea, you KNOW we had a full-ass meal around here.
#BirthdaysAreForEating
© 2021 Cookin’ & Cussin’